PizzaDowntown Nashville

⭐ Sam Score: 7.4/10
📅 Visited: July 18, 2026
📍 Address: 5056 Broadway, Suite B-103, Nashville, TN 37203
💰 Price: $$
🍽️ Cuisine: Pizza
🚗 Parking: Paid parking nearby
📞 Phone: (629) 317-8644
🌐 Website: locations.princestreetpizza.com/nashville

❤️ Great For:

My Video Review

About Prince St. Pizza

Prince St. Pizza traces back to 2012 in New York's Nolita neighborhood, built on recipes that have stayed in the Morano family for generations, their philosophy is simple: if it works on pasta, it works on pizza. The original NYC shop made its name on the Sicilian "SoHo Square," a thick, crispy-bottomed slice, and the Spicy Spring, its signature square topped with pepperoni cups, fresh mozzarella, and tomato sauce. The brand has since expanded well beyond New York, and this location, inside the Fifth + Broadway development in downtown Nashville, is its first in Tennessee.

What I Ordered

The Spicy Vodka, The Naughty Pie, and the Houston Jalapeno, three square slices, three very different heat levels.

Photos

Prince St. Pizza storefront and patio seating, Fifth + Broadway, Nashville

Prince St. Pizza's display case with fresh square slices, Nashville

Sam's order: three square slices in the box, Prince St. Pizza Nashville

Sam holding a Prince St. Pizza box, home of the spicy pepperoni

Pros & Cons

👍 Pros

Quick
Not super expensive
Lots of options
Close to Broadway

👎 Cons

Small seating area
Not 100% fresh unless you order a whole pie

Sam Score

7.4/ 10

🎁 Deals I Actually Use

A few things I personally use to eat out and get around, here's how you can save (or earn) too.

Amex Gold Card Great everyday points on food & travel Learn More → Amex Platinum Card Even better points on travel Learn More → Uber Sign up for an easy ride to your next meal Learn More → Uber Eats Get your next meal delivered Learn More →

These are referral links, if you sign up, I may earn rewards too. Thanks for supporting the site!

Prince St. Pizza appears on:

Prince St. Pizza Review (2026)